CT License Number HIC.0645155
Putnam County License NY License #pc8403
Weschester county license WC-36578-H23

Should You Replace or Repair Your Roof?

Northland Roofing, LLC

24 Hour Service - Insurance Specialists - 15 Year Warranty

Request Estimate

Should You Replace or Repair Your Roof?

Serving Dutchess County, Fairfield County, Litchfield County, New Haven County & Putnam County.

It’s only a matter of time until your roof gets damaged. Since it’s always getting hit by rainfall and heavy winds, you’ll need a repair or roof replacement at some point. We can usually fix a simple leak with a roof repair, but sometimes it’s more cost-effective for you to get a new roof.

Northland Roofing, LLC has a team of experienced professionals for your roofing needs. We can help you through every step of the process, beginning with the decision between a repair or replacement. We’ll base our suggestion on your roof damage and your choice of roof materials.

Feel free to call us today with any questions, or keep reading to find out more!

Extent of Damages

The cost of a roof repair is generally lower than paying for a new roof. However, it comes down to structural damages. If the damages are bad enough for your roof, you might save with a roof replacement.

If water gets into your roof, for example, you might end up with bacterial mold. This can weaken the roof deck, which holds up your roof. The underlayment can also be soaked through, or your roofing materials might have reached their lifespan. Either way, we’ll help with the decision!

Choosing Your Materials

We’ve been doing this for a long time, so we know the materials that our customers usually go with. Most of the time, homeowners like wood, slate, flat roof, tile, and asphalt shingles. The latter is the most common, for its affordability and durability. 

They can all be replaced or repaired, so a lot of the choice comes down to longevity and protection. Many business owners go with a Flat Roof System. This brings several additional choices, from alternate materials to modern installation.

Flat roofing is also preferred by commercial structures for the cost benefits. On that note, homeowners like asphalt shingles for the same reason. They’re inexpensive and hold up well to the elements. They don’t last as long as other materials, but they’re still cheaper to replace.

Slate has a lifespan stretching past 100 years with proper maintenance. It brings one of the best protections for your home among roofing materials, but it’s also one of the most expensive. Still, it’s worth considering for the lifespan.

Tile is similar to slate in that sense. It’s long-lasting, but the cost is balanced. A lot of homeowners enjoy tile on their roof, but you’ll have to decide if the investment is worth it. Tile offers a lot of aesthetic options, though, which is a big plus for many customers.

Of the 5, wood is one that we see less of. It’s got a distinct, rustic look, but you’ll pay for the look and wood can take more upkeep than some of the roofing materials. All of these materials are good options, so we’ll help you figure out which one is best for your needs.

To Repair or Replace; That’s the Question

The materials you want for your roof can also depend on which service you need done. For example, it might be more cost-efficient to mass repair your roof if you have tile or slate up there. 

That’s because the material cost is so high, so we’ll suggest repairs unless your roof has been there at least 70 years or the damages are too bad. Wood, on the other hand, isn’t really worth repairing if the damages are extensive. In fact, we might even suggest an alternate material.

You might be wondering why we’d suggest changing out the wood. Despite the unique aesthetic of natural wood on your roof, it’s just not worth it in most cases. The upkeep costs and the reduced lifespan can end up costing you more than you’ll probably want to pay.

On top of that, some areas don’t allow wood roofing due to the fire hazard that it poses. As usual, we recommend a professional roofer because we know the local safety codes. This brings us to asphalt shingles, which are the most common choice among homeowners.

Shingles are less expensive, so they’re cheaper to replace. Because of that, we can replace your shingles multiple times before you end up near the cost of a different material being installed in the first place. However, they don’t have the longevity of some other materials.

As shingles get old or damaged, they can crack, peel, or fall off. Heavy winds can also blow them off, or tall tree branches can wreak havoc. Asphalt shingles are hard to decide between the cost of a repair or a replacement, so we’ll put our experience to work.

That’s why it’s so important to have your free inspection by Northland Roofing, LLC. Our experts know what they’re looking at, so we’ll find out the extent of your roofing damages. If you need a roof repair or replacement, give us a call today and let us know!

We show up for a lot of searches on Google, including:


If you’re thinking about roof replacement or any other type of exterior service – give us a call today!


Roof Repair

Get Your Roof Fixed Fast!

Get an inspection and estimate. We'll have someone out right away. Click to learn more or call to schedule!
Roof Repair

Roof Replacement

24 Hour Roof Replacement

We're able to complete most roof replacements in one day! Click to learn more or call to schedule your inspection and estimate.
Roof Replacement

Vinyl Siding

Vinyl Siding

Many customers hire us to help with other exterior components for their home - including vinyl siding repairs and replacement.
Vinyl Siding Services

Gutters & Gutter Guards

Gutters & Gutter Guards

We can help with gutter cleaning, repairs, replacements, and gutter guard installations - many customers bundle this service with roofing and siding projects!
Gutter Services


Fast Service!

Same Day Repairs Available!

In many instances we are able to get a crew to your location to complete a repair the same day you contact us.

We Work Weekends!

Your life, your schedule!

We understand that you can't just drop everything going on in life when your roof needs work. That's why we're available on Saturday and Sunday!

Locally Owned!

We live here too!

We're a well established, local company - not storm chasers or some big corporation. We live in the area, are proud to be a part of the community, and love showing off our work to our friends and family. Rest assured that we take pride in taking care of our neighborhood!

Northland Roofing, LLC

24/7 Emergency Service

15 Year Replacement Warranty*

1 Year Repair Warranty*

Financing Options Available*

Top Roofer Serving CT & NY

service card two
*Restrictions apply, ask for details
gmb photo

Northland Roofing, LLC


google logo
Gave a quick accurate quote with multiple options. Responded super quickly and clearly. Showed up next day and finished project as discussed.
the letter m
Roof Repair
Antonio was terrific. He responded quickly to my roofing needs, did excellent work, gave a fair price, and was very pleasant. Highly recommend him!
letter v
Roof Replacement
Just got my roof done and I am very satisfied with the results. These guys were punctual and professional and gave me a very reasonable price. Definitely recommend this company.
Roof Replacement
I highly recommend Northland Roofing. The work, materials used and clean up were perfection and all came at a very good price.
Roofing Repairs